Essay on Leibovitz and Nachtwey

　　　In last two classes we watched “Annie Leibovitz: Life through a lens” (2008) and “James Nachtwey: War Photographer (2001)”. Leibovitz and Nachtwey are photographers from the United States. Though they are both great photographer their backgrounds and styles are different in many ways.

　　　First of all Annie Leibovitz is from a big family with six siblings. Her family used to travel a lot by car and the views from the car window were like variety of pictures to her. When she started to go to school her interests in art became bigger and especially she worked hard on photography. She has worked in many different fields but her career at the Rolling Stones magazine affected a lot on her life. She often takes pictures of famous celebrities with arty concepts. However the people who are taken by Leibovitz say they are completely comfortable to be taken pictures by her. That is not only because her reliable career backgrounds but also her personality that she tries to bring her idea and ask people about their ideas as well. There are many of her pictures have vivid colors like “Alice in Wonderland” (2003). I like those pictures because even though the main object of pictures is Alice, my eyes never get bored but not bothered by other objects either. Everything in these pictures entertains in its own ways. 

 

Annie Leibovitz: Photo from V:olta

 

Annie Leibovitz: Photo from Flickr by Duy's Photo Shoots

　　　The picture of Leonardo Dicaprio is a black and white picture but I like this one as much as her pictures with color. Its composition suits to the simplicity of the object and texture of grass and Dicaprio’s hair reflect each other.

 

　　　Next photographer, James Nachtwey is a war photographer who has been to many battlefields and countries suffering from poverty to take photos. 　　　

 

James Nachtwey: South Africa, 2000 - Grandmother cared for young girl affected by HIV.

 James Nachtwey: A homeless couple in Jakarta, Indonesia, sleeps on the railroad tracks. 

　　　He wants to take pictures because he thinks his job is to give people in those countries a voice by taking their pictures. Also he figures that photography is a form of communication and not art. Since the objects that he takes picture of are often war, he has never been happy about his works. If you compare to his pictures with pictures of Leibovitz you can easily find there are many differences. For example, obviously the objects are totally different and there are no setups or beforehand plans for most of the pictures of Nachtwey.

 　　　As similar points both of their pictures do not have superfluous objects in the pictures. Which means what they are trying to show or tell is clear and easily understandable. Also they both think that the pictures are communication tool in some ways. Overall I found that photography could be a great communication tool or entertainment as a piece of art when I watched about Annie Leibovitz. However the war photography can be still controversial in a way to take photos sometimes without permission. In a movie nobody gets mad at Nachtwey but I do not think that every single people willingly allow to take photos of their misery or loss even though it might help their situation or country.